Well, I was trying my best today to piss some people off, athough they probably misinterpreted me when I walked into a room full of sabbaticals and student officers watching a live broadcast from the House of Commons. Realising what our esteemed leader (Mr Blair, that is) was talking about, I declared loudly "Oh, it’s all this tuition fee bollocks again", and walked back out. Now what I didn’t make clear was that I think the issue of tution fees is very important, but that I think the Union are doing a fantastic job of cocking up our policy.
The primary channel for informing the student body has been a marvelous set of "press releases". From the overly hurried Student Fees - Union’s Response (response to what exactly? I know the answer, but that’s not a good press release), moving on through the unanimous rejection of tuition fees, through a wonderful MORI poll (given the choice of certain death or a kick in the teeth, 70% of the UK population asked for dental attention), we finally (if only) come to the latest report - Student Reaction to Higher Education White Paper. I saw them drafting this press release, and I think that they must have got confused - surely 28 bullet points, and no paragraphs, would be the draft itself?
I could compare some of the bullet points with the quote by Sen - I got the feeling of déjà vu, but at least Sen used the word ‘compromise’, whereas the official press release uses the phrase ‘dumb down’. I know the release is allegedly written by Sen, but nothing here happens without a committee sticking their oar in, so I’ll not blame the hideous choice of phrase on him alone. The graduate employment section is fabulous - exactly how would I not benefit the UK by working in the City?
I was there when the Union decided that they were absolutely opposed to graduate taxes, and the solution to the funding crises in Higher Education was to convert universities into vocational colleges but keep the same HE budget (and then the solution to the funding crises in Further Education would be…), so what has happened? Instead of continuing the blanket opposition, they are scrabbling around with ideas like you don’t have to pay graduate tax until you earn more than the national average, which, seeing as some people earn an awful lot of money, means that you won’t have to pay for your tuition until you earn more than most people. Huh? Perhaps, as I might have mentioned already, the graduate tax policy that the Union decided on wasn’t thought through properly.
Well, at least some people will be pretty pleased with what the Union has achieved. The students involved obviously will be congratulating each other, but I would reckon that Downing Street will be quite happy with our press release too. I wouldn’t be losing any sleep over it, if I was a government official reading it over and working out a game plan.
And don’t, whatever you do, get me started on the Tuition Fees Working Group Mantra that was attached to Sen’s door for the past few weeks.